Criminal Defense Lawyers

Annulment vs. Divorce vs. Legal Separation in New York

Last Updated on: 31st March 2025, 10:47 pm

ANNULMENT VS. DIVORCE VS. LEGAL SEPARATION IN NEW YORK

If you’re here, it’s because your marriage in New York is in trouble—or feels like it might be heading there. Maybe you need to know if annulment is even possible. Perhaps you’re thinking about separation. Or maybe you suspect that a straight divorce is the only answer. We get it, and we’re here to talk about the real differences. I’ll cut through your excuses and tell you exactly what you need to know.

We are Spodek Law Group, a nationwide federal defense law firm created by Todd Spodek. Although we handle major, high-profile legal issues, we also help people like you navigate marriage dissolutions across NYC, Long Island, and other parts of New York state. Regardless of your location, we can help you—and we don’t sugarcoat anything.

WHAT IS AN ANNULMENT IN NEW YORK?

In New York, an annulment is a court declaration that basically says your marriage was never valid from day one. Yes, it sounds extreme. In places like Queens County or Buffalo, people occasionally seek annulments for religious or personal reasons. But you can’t get one simply because you were married for a short time or you regret your decision. New York courts only grant annulments if you fit one of the strict legal grounds. It might be bigamy, it might be fraud that goes to the heart of the marriage, or it might be your spouse was underage.

If the court agrees that your marriage is void or voidable, you end up legally single, as if the marriage never existed. Consequence: you can remarry, and you walk away without the “divorce” label. But be warned: if children were born, the court still orders child support. Child support is mandatory. The court can also order spousal support if it’s fair—no free passes. If your spouse tries to hide assets or do something criminal, we can and will call that out. You don’t get to pretend none of those financial obligations ever happened just because you want the marriage void. For details on New York annulment rules, you can check the official NY Courts website.

HOW A DIVORCE DIFFERS

Divorce is the legal end of a real, valid marriage. In our state, the main advantage is that you don’t need a reason beyond “irretrievable breakdown” for six months. That’s New York’s “no-fault” ground. Nobody has to prove cheating or cruelty. Of course, you can still file on fault grounds, like abandonment or adultery, if you want to. But it’s often a waste of time unless you have a strategic reason. In NYC, most divorces move under the no-fault approach now. Consequence: once the court signs your Judgment of Divorce, you are free to remarry, but you bear the mark of being “divorced.” Yes, it’s a label, but for many people, it’s simpler than trying to meet the tough annulment requirements.

Here’s where local nuance matters. In certain upstate counties, divorce judges may push you to attempt settlement or mediation. In the five boroughs (Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island), the courts tend to see heavier caseloads, which can slow things down. Regardless, you still have to work out property division, child custody, and child support. If you fail to address those issues, the judge won’t sign off on your final divorce. Child support is not optional. If you try to escape your obligations, you can face wage garnishments and even criminal contempt. Don’t test the court—it won’t end well.

Here’s a consequence: Equitable distribution can land you paying your spouse for half the house you bought alone. That might sting, but it’s how New York law works. If you’re accused of hiding assets, you might face serious legal penalties for contempt or even fraud. Our Spodek Law Group attorneys are ready to defend you, but only if you’re honest. If you lie to us or hold back crucial facts, we’ll call you out for it. The best strategy is full disclosure so we can negotiate or fight effectively.

LEGAL SEPARATION: STILL MARRIED, BUT LIVING APART

Unlike an annulment or divorce, a legal separation means you remain married, but you set formal rules for living apart. This can happen through a written separation agreement you both sign (and potentially file with the county clerk), or by getting a court Judgment of Separation (less common). In Buffalo or Rochester, some couples use separation to remain on a spouse’s health insurance, or for religious reasons. They don’t want the “stigma” of divorce, or they hope to reconcile later.

Consequence: you can’t remarry. If you try, it’s bigamy. A legal separation might be wise if you’re not quite ready to divorce, but you want rules about who pays which bills, who stays in the marital home, and how child support works. Yes, you still must cover child support. Some folks use separation as a stepping stone: after one year, you can convert that separation into a divorce more easily. But if you choose to linger in separation indefinitely, you’re risking future legal tangles if you or your spouse decides to buy property or move out of state. We’ve seen people come to us years later, in a complicated dispute over assets that never got divided. That’s on you if you refuse to finalize your divorce, and later it blows up.

FINANCIAL OBLIGATIONS IN ALL THREE SCENARIOS

Here’s the reality: you don’t get to walk away from marital responsibilities no matter how you end your marriage. In an annulment, the court can still divide assets you acquired as a couple and force spousal maintenance if justified. In a divorce, you will deal with equitable distribution, and you might pay or receive alimony. Under a legal separation, you remain on the hook for child support and possibly spousal support if your spouse needs it.

If you think you can outsmart the system, think again. The courts in NYC and the rest of the state won’t give you a free pass just because you claim you never wanted to be married in the first place. I’d rather you hear it from me—rather than find out the hard way when a judge orders your wages garnished.

IMMIGRATION STATUS WARNING

In some cases, the marriage you’re dissolving involves immigration benefits. Annulment can wipe out those benefits, because legally the marriage never existed. Consequence: your spouse—or you—could lose the chance at a green card if that marriage was the basis. Divorce is less destructive: it shows the marriage was real, but now ended, so in some immigration contexts, there is still a path (like a waiver for a conditional resident). A legal separation may raise red flags if you’re trying to prove you live together as a genuine couple, so expect scrutiny at USCIS interviews. If you try to commit immigration fraud or present false documents to the court, you could be facing criminal charges. Yes, that’s jail time territory. We don’t play with that nonsense.

WHICH OPTION FITS YOUR NEEDS?

Annulment: Rare and requires strict grounds. If you succeed, you wipe out the marriage. But you can still owe spousal support or child support if the court says so.

Divorce: The usual route. It acknowledges a valid marriage that now ends. You must deal with property division, child custody, and support. Once it’s final, you’re single again.

Legal Separation: You keep the marriage status but live apart under a formal agreement or court order. You can’t remarry, and you still have to handle child support, spousal maintenance, or dividing some bills.

You might think a separation is easier than a divorce—but you’re not off the hook for legal obligations. If you refuse to finalize things, you could regret it later if your spouse racks up debt or if you want to remarry. Decide wisely. Don’t assume you can half-leave a marriage without consequences.

SIMPLE COMPARISON TABLE

IF THERE’S FRAUD OR CRIME INVOLVED

Some individuals in Brooklyn or elsewhere think they can claim “fraud” to get a quick annulment. That’s not how it works. If you scream “fraud,” you need proof that goes to the essence of the marriage. For instance, your spouse never told you they were already married. That’s bigamy—obviously a crime. If you suspect your spouse used you for immigration papers, you’d need solid evidence. Courts don’t believe every story of “they only wanted a green card.” Show it, or you’ll be the one wasting time in court. If bigamy is proven, your spouse could face criminal charges for a second marriage. Potentially, that means jail. If you’re the bigamist, don’t come whining later that you didn’t realize your prior divorce wasn’t finalized. The law won’t care about your excuses.

STRATEGIES FOR PROTECTION

I won’t tolerate your self-sabotage. If you come to us for help, but keep lying or withholding details, you’re digging your own grave. Here’s the tough talk approach:

• Full Disclosure: If we don’t know everything—like hidden assets or prior marriages—expect your case to blow up later. We can’t defend you if you lie.
• Gather Documents: Bank statements, marriage certificates, health insurance info, birth certificates. In New York, the courts expect proof. Don’t cry victim when the judge demands documentation.
• Child Support Realities: You can’t avoid paying if you’re the higher earner. Don’t try. If you refuse, the court can seize wages, suspend licenses, or jail you. That’s statewide, from Montauk to Buffalo.
• Immigration Impact: If a green card is involved, talk to an immigration attorney. An annulment might blow up your spouse’s status or your own. That might be what you want—but do it legally. No shady tactics.
• Be Prepared to Defend or Settle: Some cases end up in a full trial, others settle. It depends on your cooperation and how complicated your finances are. If you want to fight, we’ll fight hard. If you prefer settlement, we’ll negotiate. Just don’t waffle and waste everyone’s time.

OUR ROLE: SPODEK LAW GROUP’S APPROACH

We are a top rated law firm with offices throughout Long Island and NYC. Our team understands that ending a marriage—by annulment, divorce, or separation—can get messy. We’ve handled high-stakes marital disputes, from spouses who tried to shield assets to cases involving allegations of bigamy. Our philosophy is simple: we tell you the truth, even if it stings. We call out any excuses that might sabotage your case. Then we craft a precise legal strategy—one that maximizes your odds of a fair outcome.

If you choose to drag your feet or hide assets, guess what? The court will slap you with sanctions, and we might drop you as a client. We refuse to let you torch your own future. Instead, if you listen to our advice, stay honest, and hand over the documents we need, we can build a strong defense or negotiation strategy. That’s how you avoid paying more alimony than necessary. That’s how you maintain your credibility with the judge.

WHAT SHOULD YOU DO NEXT?

If you’re stuck in a bad marriage but don’t know whether to seek an annulment, a divorce, or just separate, consider this:

• Check if New York’s Domestic Relations Law even allows annulment under your facts.
• Think about the downside of a long separation (you stay legally married and must trust your spouse not to do financial damage).
• Realize divorce can be straightforward with New York’s no-fault ground, but you have to settle or litigate property and custody issues.
• Speak with an attorney who will be direct, not someone who promises you a magical quick fix.

Yes, you might feel intimidated. Yes, it can be stressful. But if you do nothing and let your problems fester, you risk bigger issues—like watching your spouse drain your bank accounts or incurring potential criminal liability if there’s fraud involved. Procrastination is your enemy.

CONTACT OUR TEAM FOR A RISK-FREE CONSULTATION

At Spodek Law Group, we are available 24/7. This is not empty talk—we genuinely pick up or get back to you ASAP. We know that families in NYC, Long Island, or Upstate face unique legal concerns. Whether you suspect an invalid marriage or want to pursue a straightforward divorce, we can help you plan your next move. We’ll call you out if you’re making excuses or if you’re sabotaging yourself. That might seem harsh, but it’s exactly how we safeguard your future.

Disclaimer: This article does not create an attorney-client relationship and is not specific legal advice. For actual legal guidance about annulment, divorce, or separation in New York, contact a licensed attorney or visit the New York Courts website for more general info. Every case is different. Results vary. Speak to our team if you want real answers.

Final Word: stop hesitating. Make a decision that protects you and your children if you have them. If you do nothing, you’re begging for disaster. Let’s get this handled—right now.