Blog
Grand Jury Representation
If you’re on our website, it’s because you’re in legal trouble – and need the best possible defense attorney. At Spodek Law Group – we understand that, and take this very seriously. We have offices throughout Long Island and NYC, and our team of attorneys has over 50 years of combined experience dealing with some of the toughest criminal defense issues nationwide. Regardless of where your case is, or the situation you’re dealing with, we can help you.
This article focuses on grand jury representation—an aspect of criminal defense that can determine whether you face an indictment in the first place. We’ll walk you through the basics: what a grand jury is, how it operates, why prosecutors use it, and how the Spodek Law Group approaches your defense. If you’re reading this, it’s likely the grand jury process is on your radar. Our goal is to give you the information you need, and to help you understand that hiring an attorney now can make a huge difference in your case.
II. Overview of the Grand Jury
A. What Is a Grand Jury?
A grand jury is a panel of citizens convened to determine whether probable cause exists to charge someone with a crime. It’s different from a trial jury, which decides guilt or innocence beyond a reasonable doubt. A grand jury’s function is to decide whether there’s enough evidence for an indictment. Federal law, under the Fifth Amendment, typically requires an indictment by a grand jury for serious charges. Some states do as well, while others use preliminary hearings. Regardless, when the government believes you might have committed a crime, a grand jury can become the pivotal step that sets the stage for a formal prosecution.
B. Why It Matters
If the grand jury returns a “true bill,” that means you’ll likely face felony charges in court. A “no-bill” means they didn’t find sufficient evidence—so you avoid charges for the time being. Many states allow prosecutors to re-present the same case if new evidence appears, which is why early and thorough legal representation can be key. Our law firm services an extremely curated clientele that wants the best possible legal representation and is educated in knowing what makes an attorney the best. That’s relevant here because when the stakes are high, the government has nearly unlimited resources. Having a seasoned legal team on your side can help level the playing field.
C. The Power of Secrecy
Grand jury proceedings are conducted in secret. Only the prosecutor, the grand jurors, a court reporter (in most jurisdictions), and the witness are in the room. Defense attorneys generally cannot be present while their client testifies. This secrecy is meant to protect the integrity of the investigation and the reputation of the accused if no charges follow. But it also means the defense can’t challenge evidence in real-time. As a result, a thorough pre-indictment strategy is essential to protect you.
III. Legal Framework Governing Grand Juries
A. Constitutional Basis
Under the Fifth Amendment, for federal felony offenses, prosecutors usually must seek an indictment from a grand jury. States vary: some have laws mirroring the Fifth Amendment, while others use preliminary hearings. At Spodek Law Group, we believe in staying updated on each jurisdiction’s rules so we can handle cases from coast to coast.
B. Rule 6 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure
Federal grand juries operate under Rule 6, which covers selection, secrecy, subpoenas, and procedures. Rule 6 also allows prosecutors to present various types of evidence—sometimes including hearsay—that might not be admissible at trial. That’s why it’s vital to hire a legal team who understands how to potentially challenge such evidence later.
C. State Laws and Statutory Provisions
Many states have their own grand jury statutes, which can differ from federal rules. For example, New York has state-level grand jury regulations that allow certain defendants limited opportunities to testify with counsel in the room. Whatever the forum, the purpose is the same: a grand jury decides whether there’s a valid reason to bring felony charges. Our attorneys keep track of these nuances when handling multi-state matters.
IV. The Role of Prosecutors in Grand Jury Proceedings
A. Prosecutorial Influence
Prosecutors generally control the grand jury process. They choose which witnesses to call, what evidence to present, and how to frame the narrative. Unlike trial, there’s no judge ruling on objections, which means the grand jury usually hears only what the prosecutor wants them to hear. This can make the process feel skewed, but it’s part of the legal system—so understanding it is key.
B. Presentation of Evidence
Because the rules are more flexible, prosecutors can introduce testimony from law enforcement, alleged victims, experts, or even hearsay sources. Documentary evidence, like bank records or emails, may also be shown. Our job is to anticipate what they might present, so we can advise you accordingly. For instance, if we suspect the prosecutor’s evidence relies on questionable sources, we’ll plan to challenge its admissibility when the formal case moves forward.
C. Guiding the Grand Jury
A grand jury deliberates and votes in secret, but they largely rely on prosecutors to explain legal standards like probable cause. If the prosecutor believes there’s probable cause, they’ll usually push for an indictment. That’s why indicted cases are so common. However, if we get involved early, we might present exculpatory information or negotiate with the prosecutor pre-indictment. This is one of the reasons we’re recognized for handling tough cases nationwide.
V. Right to Counsel and Representation During Grand Jury
A. In-Room vs. Outside Counsel
Generally, you do not have the right to have your attorney in the grand jury room with you if you’re called to testify. You can step outside to consult your attorney after each question if needed. This can feel daunting since you don’t have someone objecting for you on the spot. Our solution is thorough preparation—ensuring that you’re ready to answer questions succinctly, assert privileges where needed, and avoid missteps.
B. Target, Subject, or Witness
Grand juries often categorize people as targets, subjects, or witnesses. If you’re a target, it typically means the government has evidence pointing directly at you. If you’re a subject, you might be involved, but they’re not yet certain of your liability. If you’re just a witness, theoretically you have minimal exposure. However, these labels can change fast. Our attorneys will assess your risk level, so we can decide on the best defense strategy.
C. The Fifth Amendment
If you’re called to testify before a grand jury and your answers might incriminate you, you can assert your Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. Whether to testify or assert the Fifth is a critical decision. We’ll advise you based on your specific circumstances. In some cases, it may be better to remain silent, especially if the government’s evidence is weak. In others, a well-prepared statement might prevent an indictment.
D. Consultation and Preparation
We pride ourselves on having a rock star team of attorneys who walk you through each potential question. We simulate grand jury scenarios so that you’re prepared for anything. If you need to step out of the grand jury room to consult your lawyer, we make sure you know how to do it efficiently, without confusing the jurors or signaling guilt. Our objective is to protect you from mistakes that can cost you your freedom.
VI. Pre-Grand Jury Preparation: Defense Strategy
A. Assessing the Government’s Case
Our first step is to figure out what evidence the prosecutor has. We review any discovery materials we can obtain, speak to potential witnesses, and examine public records. This helps us understand how strong—or weak—the government’s argument might be.
B. Negotiating Before Indictment
If we see an opportunity to resolve the matter before the grand jury votes, we might speak with the prosecutor. Sometimes, providing exculpatory documents or background information convinces the prosecutor that the case isn’t as strong as they thought. In other scenarios, we could explore a plea that avoids more severe charges. Regardless, we want to resolve cases successfully and in a way that’s beneficial to you.
C. Roleplaying Testimony
We practice with you, going through likely questions and worst-case scenarios. By the time you walk into the grand jury room, you’ll know what to say and what not to say. This approach helps clients feel confident. Our law firm has a simple belief: criminal defense lawyers should only take on clients who they can help. That means we’re thorough from day one.
D. Considering Immunity
If the government offers you immunity to secure your testimony, we’ll discuss the pros and cons. Immunity can shield you from prosecution for certain offenses, but it also removes your right to refuse to answer. If you lie or omit key facts after getting immunity, you can face perjury or obstruction charges. That’s why we help you weigh any immunity deal carefully.
VII. The Grand Jury Process: Step-by-Step
- Grand Jury Selection
Jurors are chosen from voter rolls or driver’s licenses. They serve for a set term, such as 18 months in federal courts. - Evidence Presentation
The prosecutor calls witnesses, presents documents, or plays recordings. There is no judge to rule on objections. - Testimony
If subpoenaed, you appear and answer questions under oath. You can step out to consult your attorney as needed. - Deliberations
Grand jurors meet privately to discuss the evidence and decide if probable cause exists. - Outcome
A “true bill” is an indictment. A “no-bill” ends the matter, though the prosecutor can re-present the same evidence later if new information arises.
VIII. Key Rights and Protections for the Witness or Target
A. Fifth Amendment Privilege
Your right against self-incrimination is fundamental. If answering a question could expose you to criminal liability, we encourage you to discuss this with your attorney beforehand. Once you start answering on a topic, you might waive the privilege for that area—so you must be strategic.
B. Attorney-Client Privilege
Everything you share with us is confidential, unless it’s about an ongoing plan to commit a crime. This means you can speak openly, knowing we’re here to advocate for your best interests. This helps us craft a strategy that protects you at every stage.
C. Challenging Unlawful Searches
We look closely at how evidence was obtained. If law enforcement overstepped constitutional boundaries, we can move to suppress that evidence if you’re indicted. In a grand jury setting, we can’t assert those motions yet, but we preserve the argument for later.
D. Prosecutorial Misconduct
If a prosecutor withholds exculpatory evidence or misleads the grand jury, it could be misconduct. While courts are hesitant to dismiss indictments on these grounds, it’s possible if the misconduct undermined the integrity of the proceeding. We track these issues meticulously.
IX. Strategic Considerations for Defense Attorneys
A. Whether to Testify
Choosing to testify is a major decision. If the government’s evidence is overwhelmingly weak, sometimes silence is your best ally. Other times, offering your side early can prevent an indictment by clearing up any misunderstandings. We help you weigh these options with honesty and precision.
B. Handling Document Subpoenas
Grand jury subpoenas for documents are common. We review them carefully to see if they’re overly broad, and we might negotiate with the prosecution for a narrower scope. If we believe privileged information is at stake, we’ll object to handing those materials over.
C. Preserving Issues for Post-Indictment
We keep diligent notes in case the government violates your rights. After an indictment, we can file motions to dismiss or motions to suppress evidence. Our only objective is to get the case against you dismissed, or significantly diminished, if possible.
D. Managing Publicity
Sometimes, high-profile cases generate media interest. While grand jury proceedings are secret, leaks can happen. We focus on safeguarding your reputation. Our attorneys have been seen on major news outlets such as NYPost, Fox 5, and Insider.com, so we know how to handle public scrutiny if it arises.
X. After the Grand Jury: Indictment or No Indictment
A. If You’re Indicted
If there’s a true bill, you’ll be formally charged. We’ll appear at your arraignment, discuss bail or release conditions, and begin preparing a defense. We might file motions to inspect grand jury minutes, or move to dismiss if we see prosecutorial misconduct.
B. If You’re Not Indicted
If you get a no-bill, the immediate investigation ends. However, the prosecutor can potentially re-present the case if new evidence appears. We stay vigilant and advise you on best practices to avoid giving law enforcement more ammunition down the line.
C. Impact on Witnesses
Witnesses who testify can face perjury charges if they lie, or risk self-incrimination if they speak too freely. This is why it’s critical to work with an attorney who can guide you on how to handle a subpoena, and whether it’s in your best interest to speak at all.
XI. Common Misconceptions About Grand Juries
| Misconception | Reality |
|---|---|
| “My attorney can argue my case in the grand jury.” | Generally, your attorney is not allowed inside the grand jury room, though you can step out to consult privately. |
| “No indictment means I’m fully exonerated.” | Prosecutors can re-present evidence later if they find something new. |
| “It’s the same as a trial jury.” | A grand jury only decides probable cause, not guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. |
| “The grand jury needs a solid proof of guilt to indict.” | The standard is ‘probable cause,’ which is much lower than beyond a reasonable doubt. |
XII. High-Profile Cases and Lessons Learned
At Spodek Law Group, we’ve been involved in cases that drew national attention. We represented Anna Delvey (Anna Sorokin) in a matter that was featured on Netflix’s “Inventing Anna.” Our team also handled key aspects of the Ghislaine Maxwell juror misconduct scandal. Many of the cases we’re famous for handling are cases that others said were unwinnable. These experiences taught us that thorough investigation and early involvement can change the narrative, even in complex prosecutions. We believe your future is worth defending aggressively at every stage.
XIII. Practical Tips for Individuals Facing a Grand Jury Appearance
- Hire an Attorney ASAP
If you suspect a grand jury is investigating you, reach out to a criminal defense lawyer immediately. Early intervention is key. - Stay Calm and Organized
Gather relevant documents, notes, or communications. We use every document to craft your defense. - Know Your Fifth Amendment Rights
If there’s a possibility of self-incrimination, we advise you on how to invoke the Fifth correctly. - Limit Public Discussion
Don’t post on social media about your situation. You don’t want to create additional evidence that prosecutors can use. - Carefully Prepare for Testimony
We do mock question-and-answer sessions to help you get comfortable. At Spodek Law Group, we focus on providing consistent, high-quality defense strategies. - Keep an Open Line of Communication
The best outcomes often happen when you’re transparent with your attorney. Let us know everything, so we can figure out the best approach.
XIV. Conclusion
Grand jury representation can be the turning point in a serious criminal case. If you’re facing a subpoena or you suspect you’re under investigation, reach out to us. We pride ourselves on having a rock star team of attorneys, who have over 50 years of combined experience. Our law firm has a simple belief: we should only take on clients who we can truly help. This means we’re dedicated to your situation, and we use all our resources—investigators, expert witnesses, and a digital portal for secure communication—to position you for the best outcome.
Regardless of how complicated your situation is, or where in the USA you’re located, Spodek Law Group can handle your case. We’ve been recognized by major news outlets for our legal insights, and we believe in delivering the highest level of customer service. We are available 24/7 to speak with you. If you have a grand jury issue, or any criminal defense concern, contact us now. We’re prepared to go the distance and deliver the results you need.
XV. Additional Resources
A. Relevant Statutes and Rules
- Fifth Amendment, U.S. Constitution – Guarantees indictment by grand jury for serious federal crimes and protects against self-incrimination.
- Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 6 – Governs federal grand jury composition, secrecy, and procedures.
- Title 18 of the U.S. Code – Outlines federal criminal offenses, like fraud, drug trafficking, and conspiracy.
B. Federal Jurisdiction vs. State Jurisdiction
- For federal cases, the Department of Justice typically prosecutes. Federal judges follow federal rules, including mandatory minimum sentences in certain cases.
- States follow their own laws and procedural rules, which can differ significantly from federal practice.
C. Possible Penalties
- Felony Indictments can lead to prison sentences, fines, probation, and other sanctions.
- Federal Sentencing Guidelines factor in offense level, criminal history, and aggravating circumstances. Judges may deviate, but typically consider these guidelines heavily.
D. Contact Spodek Law Group
We’re available 24/7 for a risk-free consultation. When you reach out, we’ll start by reviewing your situation and discussing your options. Our only objective is to get the case against you dismissed, or significantly diminished. If you need to hire a criminal defense attorney, it’s likely the Spodek Law Group is on your radar—and capable of winning your case.