Blog
Federal Vs State Prison
Federal Vs State Prison: Everything You Need To Know
Spodek Law Group – Over 50 Years Of Combined Experience
If you’re on our website, it’s because you’re in legal trouble – and need the best criminal defense attorney. Perhaps you’ve received a target letter, or law enforcement has visited you. Maybe you’re worried you’ll be charged with a crime that could place you in either state or federal prison. At Spodek Law Group, we understand the serious situation you’re in, and we’re here to help you..
Why Does “Federal vs State” Matter?
When you’re charged with a crime, you might assume all prosecutions are the same. That’s not correct. The difference between state and federal charges is serious, and it affects the way you’re investigated, the way you’re prosecuted, and even the prison system you might end up in if convicted.
- State charges usually apply to crimes that happen within one state’s borders. Examples include burglary, simple assault, small-scale drug possession, or DUI.
- Federal charges generally apply to larger or more complex crimes that cross state lines or break specific federal laws. Think wire fraud (18 U.S.C. § 1343), conspiracy to distribute large amounts of drugs (21 U.S.C. §§ 841-846), money laundering (18 U.S.C. §§ 1956-1957), or other big white collar crimes.
Also, the Federal Sentencing Guidelines often lead to tougher sentences than state laws. If you’re on our website, it’s because you’re in legal trouble – and need the best criminal defense attorney who knows both.
Two Different Worlds: Federal vs State Prison
Clients often ask us what prison might look like if they’re convicted. No matter your situation, our criminal defense attorneys can help you. Federal and state facilities have different levels of resources and programs. Below is a short reference chart comparing the two systems.
| Factor | State Prison | Federal Prison |
|---|---|---|
| Typical Offenses | Assault, robbery, smaller drug cases | Drug conspiracies, white collar fraud, federal crimes crossing states |
| Sentencing Guidelines | Vary by state, based on local penal codes | Federal Sentencing Guidelines, mandatory minimums in many cases |
| Agency in Charge | State Department of Corrections | Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) |
| Security Levels | Vary widely, from county jails to maximum security | From minimum camps to high-security facilities (like USP, ADX) |
Our goal is always to keep you out of prison. If that’s not possible, we aim to reduce the harm as much as we can.
Where Jurisdiction Comes From
The U.S. Constitution gives the federal government certain powers under Article I, Section 8. Crimes like wire fraud (18 U.S.C. § 1343) or child pornography (18 U.S.C. § 2252) clearly fall under federal jurisdiction. Crimes that don’t involve federal agencies or cross state lines usually stay in state court.
Sometimes, you can face both state and federal charges for the same incident. Our attorneys will help you understand each step of the legal process, from potential double jeopardy to how state and federal governments handle these cases. Usually, double jeopardy doesn’t stop two different “sovereigns” (the state and the federal government) from prosecuting the same act. These situations can be tricky, but our attorneys at Spodek Law Group know how to handle them.
Defense Strategies: Roleplaying Different Scenarios
In all cases—whether state or federal—our only objective is to get the case against you dismissed, or significantly diminished. Below are hypothetical scenarios that show how we work.
Scenario 1: Large-Scale Federal Drug Conspiracy
Facts: You’re under investigation by the DEA for conspiracy to distribute a controlled substance (21 U.S.C. § 846). There might be wiretaps, undercover agents, or an informant.
Likely Penalties: Mandatory minimums can range from 5 years to life, depending on the drug amount and your past record.
Potential Defenses:
- Motion to Suppress: If officers broke Fourth Amendment rules, we can try to throw out that evidence.
- Lack of Intent: Conspiracy means you knew about it and chose to be part of it. If you didn’t do that, the prosecution might fail to prove its case.
- Entrapment: If you were pushed to commit a crime you normally wouldn’t have, we can raise an entrapment defense.
We review every piece of evidence, looking for mistakes in how the government gathered it. We explore every option and work hard to get you the best result.
Scenario 2: State-Level Assault Case
Facts: You’re accused of assault in the second degree (New York Penal Law § 120.05) after a bar fight led to someone getting hurt.
Likely Penalties: This Class D felony can carry 2 to 7 years in state prison.
Potential Defenses:
- Self-Defense: If you had a reasonable fear for your safety and used only as much force as needed, we’ll argue that in court.
- Lack of Criminal Intent: If it was an accident, or someone else actually caused the injury, that weakens the state’s case.
- Witness Credibility: If the alleged victim or other witnesses gave stories that conflict, we can highlight that to raise doubt.
We review the local penal code, look at the evidence, and decide if you have a real chance of getting charges dropped or lowered.
Scenario 3: White Collar Fraud With Federal Agents Involved
Facts: The FBI says you broke wire fraud laws (18 U.S.C. § 1343) in an investment scheme that ran across multiple states.
Likely Penalties: Federal fraud sentences often go up if victims lost large sums of money. The Federal Sentencing Guidelines can lead to long prison terms.
Potential Defenses:
- Statute of Limitations: Fraud charges often have a 5-year (sometimes 10-year) limit. If older deals are involved, we might drop those counts.
- No Intent to Defraud: If you truly believed your actions were legal business practices, the government might fail to prove its case.
- Plea Bargain: Sometimes, if the government’s evidence is strong, we explore every option and work hard to get you the best result. But if there are issues with their case, we’ll push for dismissal or go to trial.
Penalties, Other Consequences, and Life After Conviction
When you’re facing federal or state charges, prison time is only one possible outcome. You could also see fines, probation, restitution, immigration problems, or loss of professional licenses.
Our only objective is to get the case against you dismissed, or significantly diminished. If you still face penalties, we’ll push for the best possible outcome we can get.
How Do You Beat the Case?
Motions to Dismiss and Suppress
A powerful way to challenge criminal charges is by going after the government’s evidence. If a search violated your rights, or if they forced a confession, we’ll try to block that evidence. Without their main evidence, the prosecutor’s case may fall apart.
Negotiating a Favorable Plea
Not all cases go to trial. Sometimes, it makes sense to talk with the prosecutor about a lesser offense. We come from a position of strength by showing the flaws in their evidence.
Trial by Jury
If a trial is needed, we tell your side so the court sees there’s doubt about the charges. Our attorneys have decades of experience questioning witnesses, challenging the prosecution’s case, and aiming to disprove the charges against you.